A Letter For a Friend

Trigger warning: discussion involving suicide.

I just watched a beautiful movie. It was called “The Friend” and it was about a lady writer who lost a good friend and mentor to suicide. He wills her his massive dog, Apollo – a great Dane. She lives in a tiny apartment.

Anyway, it gave me an idea and I wanted to know what you think about it.

The idea was to write a letter for a friend of mine who lost her daughter to suicide. It was kind of a writing exercise for me but might me cathartic for her. Do I have a right? Would it be unkind?

What if she has expressed feelings that reading my letter might address? She could always burn it after she read it if I’m off base or totally wrong. But I know her pretty well. I don’t think I am…wrong.

I won’t do it -won’t show her this letter I wrote for her if you think it’s a bad idea. But the movie is about writer’s block in a way. She was trying to write a book with a friend about her dead friend. After some time with Apollo, she grows to understand many things, but mostly that now she can’t live without the dog.

So she writes the book in the form of letters to her dead friend about him and about Apollo and how much she missed of his life and puppyhood. It cured her writer’s block and she and Apollo got a new lease on life.

My friend’s daughter committed suicide when my kids were little. Maybe so much time has passed, I should leave it alone. It made me cry writing it, so maybe it was only cathartic for me. I mean, I was shocked and hurt too when it first happened. My kids had been friends with her, so they were also very torn up. It might even be why my youngest son cannot get over his breakups.

So what say you? Put it in the comments and I promise I will take your advice, good or bad. Right or wrong.

Of course, who is to say what’s right or wrong except God? I wonder if she is with Him. I wonder if she asked forgiveness in the last minute. She was allegedly on drugs when she did it. There were theories that she was murdered for a while, but that was floated after the funeral. Her death certificate says suicide. Only He knows.

I pray that she is. Because I want my friend to be reunited with her when she gets to heaven. I know for sure she will be there. ☺️

16 responses to “A Letter For a Friend”

Leave a reply to Kim Smyth Cancel reply

  1. We aren’t the judges in these matters, but we should not let that suggest acceptance in any way for suicide. The Lord is the judge and I am grateful that He is merciful. Blessings to you and your family and those of your friend.

    Like

    1. Thank you, Frank.
      Absolutely, you are right. That is why I hope God was merciful due to her being under the influence and not in her right mind.

      Like

  2. Have you guys ever talked about it before? If you’ve been friends for a long time maybe go with your gut feeling. Either way releasing the feelings onto paper was healthy for you.

    Like

    1. I think you’re right, Ernie. Thanks for the feedback. 🤗

      Like

  3. I’d say you are a better judge than I am of how your friend would receive your words. Pray about it and see if you feel the Holy Spirit’s leading you.

    Like

    1. Thank you, Anne. I think that is the best advice! 🤗

      Like

  4. If you discuss the letter with her, I think she should be the guide. It might be cathartic for her. And it could deepen you relationship. I’d also suggest she follow-up with her own letter.

    Like

    1. Yours is an interesting response. I’ll pray on the whole thing and let you know.

      Like

  5. I’m unsure what her healing process is and how she’s handled losing her child to suicide. Just because the exercise was a good thing for you and released what you needed to release, it doesn’t mean the same thing will happen for her.

    It could end up having the wrong effect, and she could find herself falling into a pit of depression or sadness because something that has been lying dormant and possibly resolved as best as it can be in her heart, is conjured up again.

    *Shrugs* This is a tough one. I’d say pray about it. Ask God what you should do. And if the pit of your belly leans one way and doesn’t let up, perhaps that’ll be Him responding?

    Like

    1. Sounds very reasonable. Thanks Tre. 🤗🤗

      Like

      1. Thank you, Tre. That was very helpful and also great advice! 🤗☺️

        Like

      2. Sometimes coincidences aren’t really coincidences… I read this post this morning, and I wanted to share the link with you as well.

        How I’m Living – 15 December 25

        Like

  6. Hello Kim, This is so difficult, I don’t know. I like the suggestion to let your friend know that you’ve written a letter, giving her the time to process it and whether she she would or wouldn’t like to see it.

    It’s lovely the energy going into the thoughtfulness, carefulness and consideration behind the scene. Probably more time is going to be spent in this arena than the actual letter writing!

    I have found that most people do want to talk about somebody who has passed away with a trusted and safe person, and that they really appreciate the listening ear. I trust in the almighty source of guidance, you are not doing it on your own. All the best whether you choose a path or let it lie dormant. xo

    Like

    1. Thanks, Kymber. I talked to her yesterday, but it was on a different subject and I didn’t think to bring it up. The mood was joyous around here yesterday, my youngest was visiting, and it just slipped my mind.
      I like the idea of letting her in on it and her having time to process her feelings first. Thanks for your kind feedback.

      Like